We have and continue to be guided by a simple but intuitive framework for longer-term investing. In essence, it suggests that long-term returns can be particularly rewarding when investments are made at inexpensive valuations. Likewise, investing results have proven to be less satisfying, over time, when investments were made at elevated valuation levels. Importantly, this guideline has no real bearing on investment returns from one year to the next. Rather, it has proven particularly useful for investors to use this over longer time frames to help assess the long-term return potential of various asset classes. Reflecting on this basic rule recently has led to us to ask the question: where are valuations today? And importantly, what expectations should we have for longer-term returns from equities?
On the surface, the large cap U.S. stock market, as measured by the S&P 500 index, appears expensive. That’s not that surprising given how well it has performed since the lows reached in the fall of 2022. Its forward Price to Earnings ratio, which reflects the current price divided by the earnings expected from the companies within the index over the next twelve months, currently sits at about 21. That compares to its average of 16 over the past twenty to thirty years. But, as has been well documented in recent months, the gains of the U.S. market over the past year have been heavily influenced by the performance of the “Magnificent 7”, a group of seven large technology stocks. If we strip out these seven stocks, the market’s P/E ratio falls to a more reasonable range of 17-18. In other words, the U.S. market is not cheap but may not necessarily be as expensive as one would think.
A similar story exists elsewhere. The forward P/E ratio for the Canadian equity market is just below 15, which is around its long-term average. The same ratio for overseas developed markets is also just below 15, which is slightly higher than its long-term average. In emerging markets, the ratio is nearly 12 which is also just above its longer-term average.
The key takeaway is that despite the fact equity markets have done well since the lows reached in 2022, the valuation levels, outside of some of the largest technology stocks in the world, are not necessarily at the kind of elevated levels that would suggest investors need to meaningfully recalibrate their long-term return expectations. Nevertheless, should markets continue to march forward without a meaningful pick-up in earnings, we may have to revisit this exercise as it could be indicative that markets have pulled forward some of the future return potential from the asset class.
Should you have any questions, please feel free to reach out.
Enjoy the weekend.
Mike