[MUSIC PLAYING]
Welcome to the July episode of Bay Street Views. My mission is to educate, inform, and help you sidestep financial accidents. Today, I'd like to discuss prudent ways of investing when nearly all the major asset classes, including stocks, bonds, real estate and commodities, are expensive.
Most asset categories had a stellar performance over the past year despite the economic collapse due to the pandemic. Asset valuations have stretched and, in nearly all cases, well above the previous peaks.
As the saying goes, "a picture is worth a thousand words," so let the next few charts tell the story. This chart shows the ratio of the US equity benchmark, S&P 500, to the size of the economy. This metric tells us that the US equity market is nearly twice the size of the entire American economy, far exceeding the previous records.
And this chart here shows the historical valuation for bonds measured as the amount of savings it takes to generate a minimum wage income. In other words, you've got to have roughly $2 million invested in a 10-year Government of Canada bond to generate a minimum wage income. Needless to say, this level of income won't afford you a comfortable retirement lifestyle.
Let's look at the real estate market, which hasn't been this expensive since the housing bubble in 2007. Even the broad commodity index, which includes energy, livestock, industrial metals, grains, and other agricultural items, has been on a tear. And on a more adventurous note, cryptocurrencies, a new and growing asset class, have had a parabolic rise since the last year.
Many of you may wonder what the root cause is for this gravity-defying increase in asset prices. Here's my take on this critical question. The most important price in the financial markets is the price of money, which is the interest rates set by the central bank. Interest rates have been declining for years and reached rock bottom last year at the peak of the pandemic-induced crisis.
The law of supply and demand dictates that when interest rates go down, the demand for money and credit goes up, and vice-versa. Easy access to cheap credit encouraged spending and investments, which boosted prices for nearly all asset classes. When there is too much money chasing a finite number of investment opportunities, asset prices get inflated to fantastic levels.
So what is an investor supposed to do when nearly all asset classes appear to be richly valued and susceptible to correction from these historically hefty levels? I don't encourage the market timing because it is a fool's errand. Usually, the equity markets go up and down way more than you'd expect.
The good news is you don't have to get the market timing right to be a successful investor in the long run. There are ways you can invest when the markets are high, while intelligently managing the risk in several ways.
First, let's consider a strategy through the dollar-cost averaging. This approach entails investing a fixed dollar amount over a predetermined period. Let's suppose you've sold a rental condo for $520,000 and wish to deploy the funds into stocks.
But after seeing the charts I just shared with you, you are uneasy about investing the entire amount into equities as a lump sum. Instead, you may choose to invest $10,000 per week over the next 52 weeks. So it will take you a year to get your money invested.
The main advantage of the dollar-cost averaging is it reduces the risk of investing at the top of the market. If the market drops while you are cost averaging into stocks, your weekly contributions will buy you more shares at lower prices.
Let me give you a quick example. If $10,000 is buying you 100 shares of ABC stock at $100 a share and the stock drops 10% the following week, the same $10,000 will buy you 111 shares of the same stock. Eventually, when the equity markets recover, you could make a potentially bigger profit on a greater number of shares you've acquired.
The obvious disadvantage of the proposed method is missing out on higher returns should the equity markets rally in the near term. An important question to ask yourself is this-- what will disappoint you the most-- if you invest your money as a lump sum and the markets drop 10% or you dollar-cost average, the markets rally 10%, and you miss out on that upside?
When answering this important question, please keep in mind that losing money is twice as painful as the joy of making profits. A second approach to safeguard the portfolio is by owning assets that don't move in the same direction at the same time. In other words, own assets that have a low or negative correlation to one another.
This part tends to be often confusing to investors, who naturally wish to see all of their investments go up at the same time. However, if all portfolio holdings appreciates simultaneously, there is a pretty good chance they will all go down at the same time.
We want to avoid the extreme ups and downs in the portfolio. Let me give you one of many examples illustrating how the portfolio returns can be smoothed out.
Usually, when investors are feeling great about the economic outlook, they want to own risk assets, such as equities, so stock prices go up. Meanwhile, safe-haven assets, like the US dollar, Swiss franc, Japanese yen fall out of favor, and their values decline relative to the Canadian dollar. Owning stocks that are denominated in these safe-haven currencies could help you partially mitigate the downside risk.
For example, if during the next market correction, US equity benchmark drops 10%, and meanwhile, the US dollar goes up 4% relative to the loonie, your net loss on paper would be 6%, which is better than a 10% loss. Conversely, should the US market rally 10%, chances are the greenback will decline and it will reduce your overall profit.
A third solution to diversifying risk in the portfolio is to add alternative investments, such as long/short hedge funds to the portfolio mix. The hedge fund manager would seek to profit from buying undervalued stocks and selling short the overvalued equities.
Selling short means the fund manager borrows the overvalued stock to sell in the market when the price is high. If and when that stock price falls, the fund manager buys the stock at a lower price, returns the borrowed shares to the lender, and profits the difference between the sale price and the purchase price.
Let me give you an example of this strategy. Let's assume the fund manager believes Amazon is undervalued, so they buy that stock to profit if the price goes up. Meanwhile, the manager believes IBM is overvalued, so the stock is sold short to profit if the price declines.
Let's also assume that during with the next stock market correction, Amazon and IBM drop 15% and 20%, respectively. Thus, the fund loses 15% on Amazon but makes 20% on IBM, more than offsetting the losses on Amazon.
Obviously, the strategy does not always work out this well. There is a possibility that the long and short strategies could both fail. Thereby, instead of reducing risk as desired, it might be increasing volatility and potential losses. That's why a careful selection of an experienced investment team with a long track record in this particular strategy is so crucial.
In conclusion, investing when the various asset classes are as frothy as they are today is tricky. No single line of defense in the portfolio can offer ample protection if and when the market corrects from these lofty levels.
Instead, I believe in having multiple lines of defense through dollar-cost averaging, owning assets that have a low correlation with one another, and adding some exposure to carefully chosen long/short hedge funds.
Selecting investments for an all-weather portfolio is like deciding on the type of vessel when crossing the ocean. If you're on a speed boat when crossing the ocean, and the waters are calm at all times, it might be a fun but dangerous way of traveling. Should you encounter a storm on the high seas, as it often happens, the consequences might be dire.
On the other hand, should you be on an oil tanker, it might be a less stylish way to be crossing the pond, but it would certainly be a safer way to get to the final destination. Make your portfolio be an oil tanker constructed for all weather conditions on the high seas. Be diversified.
Thank you for watching today. Stay safe and be well.
[MUSIC PLAYING]
This video is provided by RBC Wealth Management for informational purposes only. The comments contained in this video are general in nature, and do not constitute legal, investment, trust, estate, accounting or tax advice. RBC Dominion Securities Inc.*, Royal Trust Corporation of Canada, The Royal Trust Company, RBC PH&N Investment Counsel Inc., RBC Wealth Management Financial Services Inc. are affiliated corporate entities and member companies of RBC Wealth Management, a business segment of Royal Bank of Canada. *Member – Canadian Investor Protection Fund. Please visit www.rbc.com/legal/ for further information on the entities that are member companies of RBC Wealth Management. ®/TM Trademark(s) of Royal Bank of Canada. Used under license. © 2021 Royal Bank of Canada. All rights reserved.